Our Position

Tax-Exempt Credit Unions

Position

  • ICBA urges Congress to end the unwarranted federal tax subsidy of the credit union industry and/or promote increased tax parity between credit unions and community banks.
  • ICBA staunchly opposes credit unions that exploit their tax subsidy and lax regulatory environment to acquire locally based community banks and urges Congress to use its oversight authority to investigate the National Credit Union Administration’s failure to adequately regulate and supervise the industry and to adhere to the original purpose of the credit union tax exemption.
  • ICBA opposes expanded powers for credit union service organizations, which are independently owned, for profit, and not supervised by any federal agency and supports legislation that would provide NCUA with authority to examine third-party service companies.
  • ICBA opposes NCUA’s weakening of safeguards on commercial lending, field of membership and the growing use of credit union subordinated debt, which allows outside investors to exploit the credit union tax subsidy.
  • ICBA supports applying Community Reinvestment Act requirements to credit unions comparable to and with the same asset size distinctions as banks and thrifts and urges states to prohibit the placement of public deposits in tax-exempt credit unions.

Background

The credit union tax exemption is based on an outdated 100-year-old law that has never been revisited. Since that time, credit unions have become larger, more complex, and bank-like in their size, powers, product and service offerings, and fields of membership – a trend that has sharply accelerated in recent years.

It is past time to bring credit unions into the 21st century, revoke their privileged status, and tax and regulate them as we do comparable financial institutions. Credit unions were chartered by Congress to enable people of small means with a “common bond” to pool their resources to meet their basic deposit, savings and borrowing needs.

ICBA and community banks are particularly alarmed by the recent trend of credit unions acquiring banks – effectively “weaponizing” their tax subsidy and lax regulatory standards. Larger, out-of-market credit unions are displacing smaller, locally based community banks and other credit unions, creating an environment that is less competitive, has more systemic risk, and offers fewer choices for consumers and small businesses.

Credit union acquisitions of community banks and their branches have accelerated rapidly, with the last five years seeing approximately a 400 percent increase over the previous five years. These deals transform taxable business activity at community banks into tax-exempt activity at credit unions, thereby shrinking the tax base, not only at the federal level but at the state and local level as well.

Staff Contact

Michael Emancipator

SVP and Senior Regulatory Counsel

ICBA

[email protected]

Aaron Stetter

EVP, Affiliate and Volunteer Relations

ICBA

[email protected]

Christopher Cole

EVP, Senior Regulatory Counsel

ICBA

[email protected]

Related News

NCUA considering ICBA-opposed subordinated debt today

March 16, 2023

With the National Credit Union Administration meeting today on a rule to relax restrictions on issuing subordinated debt, a former NCUA official raised concerns in a recent blog post.

Background: The NCUA rule would allow credit unions to issue subordinated debt notes with maturities of longer than 20 years. The agency has said it is raising the maturity limit, which currently ranges from five to 20 years, to enable credit unions to participate in the Emergency Capital Investment Program, under which Treasury purchases subordinated debt in 15- or 30-year maturities.

New Blog Post: In a blog post this week, Callahan & Associates co-founder and former NCUA Central Liquidity Fund President Chip Filson said a key question is how much detail credit unions will be required to provide the board and public about how they source and use the funds they raise, because the interest on the debt is an operating expense that comes before member dividends. He noted that bank purchases have been an important part of some credit unions’ use of debt.

ICBA Opposition: ICBA expressed opposition to the rule in a December comment letter, noting the changes are inappropriate because they are not tailored to ECIP participation. ICBA also said the proposal increases the likelihood of credit unions selling securities that courts hold to be impermissible equity interests.

ICBA Recommendations: Instead, ICBA encouraged the NCUA to:

  • Issue regulations barring credit unions from using proceeds from the issuance of subordinated debt to purchase the assets of FDIC-insured banks.

  • Continue to limit the maturity of credit union subordinated debt to 20 years, or only permit longer maturities when the creditor is the U.S. government.

  • Require credit unions to submit written opinions from a qualified counsel and li